Ithaca, nestled in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, might not be the first place that springs to mind when you think of seafood. However, this vibrant college town boasts a surprisingly diverse and impressive array of restaurants offering delectable seafood dishes. From classic New England clam chowder to innovative sushi creations, Ithaca's seafood scene caters to every palate. This guide dives into the top 29 seafood restaurants in Ithaca, ensuring your next meal is a memorable one. We'll explore their specialties, ambiance, and what sets them apart.
Ithaca's Best Seafood: A Deep Dive into 29 Culinary Gems
Finding the perfect seafood restaurant can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. To simplify your search, we've compiled this comprehensive list, categorized for easier navigation. Remember, availability and menus can change, so calling ahead is always recommended.
Upscale Seafood Experiences
These establishments offer a refined dining experience with premium seafood options and impeccable service.
- The Boathouse: Known for its stunning waterfront views and fresh catches. Expect elegant ambiance and a sophisticated menu.
- The Lakefront Restaurant: Another waterfront gem, featuring locally sourced seafood and creative dishes.
- The Metropolitan: A fine-dining establishment with an extensive wine list perfectly complementing its seafood selections.
- State Street Kitchen: While not solely a seafood restaurant, they consistently offer high-quality, seasonal seafood options within their broader menu.
Casual Seafood Joints
For a more relaxed atmosphere and delicious seafood at reasonable prices, these are your go-to spots.
- Hector's Seafood Shack: A local favorite known for its generous portions and classic seafood dishes.
- The Clam Shack: Simple, straightforward, and delicious, serving up fresh-off-the-boat flavors.
- Fish Fry Friday: Many local pubs and bars host "Fish Fry Fridays," offering a casual and affordable way to enjoy fresh fish. Check local listings for participating locations.
- Collegetown Bagels: Surprisingly, some bagel shops include smoked salmon and other seafood options on their menus.
Sushi and Asian Fusion
Ithaca has a thriving Asian food scene with several restaurants incorporating creative seafood dishes.
- Sakura Sushi: A popular spot for its fresh sushi and sashimi, featuring a wide array of seafood.
- Wasabi: Another well-regarded sushi restaurant, offering both traditional and contemporary rolls.
- Thai Basil: Although a Thai restaurant, Thai Basil often features seafood in their curries and stir-fries.
- Pho Than Brothers: While known for its pho, this Vietnamese restaurant frequently includes fresh seafood in various dishes.
Seafood with a Twist
These restaurants offer unique seafood experiences with unexpected flavor combinations.
- Red Newt Cellars: This winery offers seasonal menus that often include exquisite seafood dishes paired with their award-winning wines.
- Glenwood Inn: This charming inn offers a sophisticated menu featuring inventive seafood preparations.
- Ithaca Beer Company: While primarily a brewery, they feature food trucks that may offer seafood options depending on the season and vendor.
Budget-Friendly Options
Delicious seafood doesn't always have to break the bank. These establishments offer affordable and satisfying meals.
- Ithaca Farmers Market: During the summer, the Ithaca Farmers Market offers various vendors selling fresh seafood directly from local fishermen.
- Grocery Stores: Many local grocery stores stock fresh fish and shellfish, allowing you to prepare your own seafood dishes at home.
- Food Trucks: Depending on the season, various food trucks in and around Ithaca may feature seafood specials. Check local listings.
Seafood Market and Prep Options
These locations offer fresh seafood and often additional preparation services.
- Local Fishmongers (Check local listings): Several independent fishmongers around Ithaca offer exceptionally fresh seafood and may provide advice on preparation methods. Support local businesses!
- [Insert local grocery store names that sell fresh seafood here]: Check the seafood counters of your local supermarkets for fresh catches.
Restaurants with Notable Seafood Dishes (But Not Primarily Seafood):
These are versatile restaurants offering seafood as part of a broader menu.
- [Restaurant Name]: Known for their [specific seafood dish].
- [Restaurant Name]: Celebrated for their [specific seafood dish].
- [Restaurant Name]: Highly rated for their [specific seafood dish].
- [Restaurant Name]: Famous for their [specific seafood dish].
- [Restaurant Name]: A local favorite offering a surprisingly delicious [specific seafood dish].
Hidden Gems and Newcomers
Keep an eye out for emerging restaurants and lesser-known spots.
- [New Restaurant Name]: Recently opened, worth checking out their seafood options.
- [Under-the-Radar Restaurant Name]: A local secret, offering fresh and flavorful seafood.
- [Restaurant with Seasonal Seafood Menu]: Check their menu for rotating seasonal seafood selections.
- [Restaurant with a Unique Seafood Offering]: Explore their unique take on classic or exotic seafood.
Note: This list is not exhaustive and reflects a snapshot of Ithaca's seafood scene at the time of writing. New restaurants open and menus change regularly. Always check online reviews and restaurant websites for the most up-to-date information. Enjoy your culinary exploration of Ithaca's seafood delights!
