Chelsea, a vibrant neighborhood in Manhattan, boasts a surprisingly diverse pizza scene. From classic New York slices to innovative gourmet pies, there's a pizza experience for everyone. This guide dives deep into the top 16 pizza places in Chelsea, ensuring your next pizza night is truly unforgettable. We've considered factors like quality of ingredients, creativity of toppings, overall atmosphere, and of course, that crucial taste.
Finding Your Perfect Chelsea Pizza Slice: A Neighborhood Guide
Chelsea's pizza landscape is as diverse as its residents. To help you navigate this delicious terrain, we've categorized our top picks:
Classic New York Style
These spots deliver on the promise of a quintessential NYC pizza experience: thin crust, simple toppings, and a taste that's both familiar and satisfying.
-
Joe's Pizza: A Chelsea institution, Joe's Pizza is known for its massive, foldable slices. Their classic cheese is a must-try, a testament to simplicity done right. Expect a line, especially during peak hours – a testament to its popularity. Pro Tip: Try their Sicilian square slice for a different texture.
-
Artichoke Basille's Pizza: While technically not in Chelsea, it's close enough to warrant a mention. Their artichoke pizza is legendary, a creamy, garlicky delight that sets them apart. It's a bit richer than your average slice, perfect for a special occasion or when you're craving something indulgent.
-
Little Italy Pizza: This unassuming spot serves up classic New York-style pizza with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients. While it might not have the same buzz as Joe's, the pizza speaks for itself. The crust has a delightful char, and their Margherita is a revelation.
Gourmet & Creative Pizzas
For those seeking something beyond the classic, Chelsea offers several pizzerias that push boundaries with unique toppings and innovative techniques.
-
Emily: Emily is a wood-fired pizza haven, offering creative pies with high-end ingredients. Their pizzas are works of art, both visually and in terms of taste. Expect unusual combinations that somehow work perfectly. Their star? The "Regina" with sausage, mushrooms and peppers.
-
Lilia: While reservations are notoriously difficult to snag, Lilia's pizzas are worth the effort. This acclaimed restaurant offers wood-fired pizzas that are lighter and airier than many traditional New York-style pies. The flavors are complex and sophisticated.
-
Una Pizza Napoletana: This is a Neapolitan-style pizza establishment, offering incredible, authentic pies. The dough is light and airy, and the toppings are simple yet bursting with flavor. It’s a refined experience, perfect for a date night or a special occasion.
Casual & Quick Bites
Sometimes, you just need a quick and satisfying pizza slice without the fuss. These spots offer great pizza without the wait or price tag of the more upscale options.
-
Pizza Suprema: A dependable choice for a no-frills, delicious pizza slice. Their selection of classic toppings and generous portion sizes make it a popular choice among locals.
-
2 Bros Pizza: Another popular spot known for its large, affordable slices. A great option for a casual, quick bite. They're known for being open late, a boon to the Chelsea night owls.
Unique & Interesting Options
Chelsea's diverse culinary scene also extends to its pizza offerings. These spots stand out for their unique approach to pizza-making:
-
Chelsea Market: While not a pizza place per se, Chelsea Market offers a variety of pizza options from different vendors, giving you a chance to sample several styles in one location. This is perfect for indecisive pizza lovers.
-
The Meatball Shop: Yes, a meatball shop! But their pizzas are surprisingly delicious, offering a unique twist on classic flavors. The combination of their house-made meatballs and their pizza dough is a must-try.
-
Rosemary's: This is an upscale restaurant, but their pizza is worth mentioning. They offer a more refined, gourmet take on pizza, featuring seasonal ingredients and a wood-fired oven.
-
Fig & Olive: This Mediterranean-inspired restaurant serves up delicious pizzas with a unique twist. Their pizzas use high-quality, fresh ingredients and offer a lighter, more flavorful experience.
Beyond the Slice: Pizza Experiences
Some Chelsea spots offer more than just a slice; they offer a complete pizza experience:
-
Via Carota: This charming West Village restaurant (a short walk from Chelsea) has a delightful, rustic ambiance and offers delicious wood-fired pizzas. It's perfect for a romantic date night or a celebratory dinner.
-
Locanda Verde: This stylish restaurant located in the Greenwich Hotel boasts a sophisticated menu with a few standout pizza options. The atmosphere is chic and sophisticated, perfect for a special occasion.
Pizza by the Pie
These spots focus on whole pizzas, great for sharing (or not!):
-
Siena Tavern: This upscale Italian restaurant offers delicious pizzas as part of its broader menu. Perfect for a special occasion or a dinner with friends.
-
The Spotted Pig: This gastropub offers a more casual setting for enjoying their pizzas, alongside their extensive beer and cocktail selection. It's a great option for a more laid-back pizza night out.
Choosing Your Chelsea Pizza Adventure
This list provides a starting point for your Chelsea pizza journey. Remember to check hours, menus, and reviews before visiting. Happy pizza hunting! And don't forget to share your favorite Chelsea pizza spot in the comments below!
