Thief, located in the heart of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, has quickly become a culinary destination known for its innovative menu and unique dining experience. This in-depth review explores Thief's menu, highlighting its strengths and weaknesses, and providing insights based on various online reviews and personal experiences. We'll delve into specific dishes, pricing, and the overall atmosphere to give you a complete picture before your visit.
Exploring Thief's Evolving Menu
Thief's menu is not static; it evolves with the seasons, incorporating fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. This commitment to freshness is a recurring theme in positive reviews. However, this fluidity can also mean some favorite dishes might disappear, leading to occasional disappointment for repeat customers.
Appetizers: Small Plates, Big Flavors
The appetizer selection at Thief is designed for sharing, encouraging a communal dining experience. Many reviewers rave about the uni (sea urchin) preparations, often cited as a highlight of the meal. Other frequently mentioned appetizers include:
- Whipped Feta with Honey and Pistachios: This classic combination is elevated by Thief's use of high-quality ingredients. The creamy feta is balanced perfectly by the sweetness of the honey and the crunch of the pistachios. Many reviewers note its deliciousness and relatively low price point.
- Octopus Salad: Reviews on the octopus salad are mixed. While some praise its tender texture and vibrant flavors, others find it slightly overcooked or lacking in seasoning. This seems to be a dish that can vary in execution.
- Roasted Bone Marrow: A more adventurous choice, the bone marrow is generally well-received by those who order it. It's often described as rich, decadent, and perfectly cooked.
Main Courses: A Blend of Modern and Classic
Thief's main courses showcase a sophisticated blend of modern culinary techniques and classic preparations. Portion sizes are generally described as moderate, making it possible to sample several dishes. Popular choices include:
- Grilled Swordfish: Consistently praised for its perfect grilling, the swordfish is a mainstay on the menu. The seasoning is subtle, allowing the natural flavor of the fish to shine.
- Pasta Dishes: Thief's pasta dishes receive high praise, with many reviewers noting the quality of the pasta and the creative sauce combinations. The specific pasta options change frequently, reflecting the seasonal menu.
- Roasted Chicken: A more classic choice, the roasted chicken is nonetheless well-executed. Reviews often mention its juicy texture and flavorful skin.
Desserts: Sweet Endings
Thief's dessert menu is smaller than its other sections, but the offerings are generally well-regarded. The most consistently praised dessert is the chocolate mousse, frequently described as rich, decadent, and perfectly balanced. Other desserts vary depending on seasonal availability.
Pricing and Value
Thief's pricing is generally considered to be in line with other upscale restaurants in Williamsburg. While not inexpensive, most reviewers feel the quality of the ingredients and the execution of the dishes justify the cost. The smaller portions encourage ordering multiple dishes, which can add up, but the overall experience seems to leave diners feeling satisfied.
Atmosphere and Service
The restaurant itself has a sophisticated, yet relaxed atmosphere. The design is modern and minimalist, creating a comfortable and inviting space. Service is generally described as attentive and knowledgeable, with staff being able to provide recommendations and answer questions about the menu.
Conclusion: Thief - A Worthy Culinary Destination
Thief offers a unique and consistently high-quality dining experience. While the menu's seasonal changes might mean some favorites come and go, the commitment to fresh, local ingredients and skilled execution shines through in every dish. If you're looking for a memorable meal in Williamsburg, Thief is definitely worth a visit. However, be prepared for a potentially higher price point and smaller portion sizes than some other restaurants in the area. Always check the online menu before your visit to ensure your favorite items are available.
