Finding the perfect tuna dish can be a culinary quest. Luckily, Ithaca boasts a diverse and exciting food scene, with many restaurants offering delicious tuna preparations. This guide explores 21 of the best tuna restaurants in Ithaca, catering to various tastes and budgets. We'll delve into what makes each spot unique, highlighting their specialties and atmosphere. Whether you crave a classic tuna melt or a sophisticated seared tuna steak, this comprehensive guide will help you find your perfect tuna haven in Ithaca.
Top Choices for Tuna Lovers in Ithaca
This section features some of our top picks for exceptional tuna dishes in Ithaca. We've considered factors like freshness of ingredients, culinary creativity, and overall dining experience.
1. The Blue Marlin Bistro: Ocean-Fresh Delights
The Blue Marlin Bistro consistently receives rave reviews for its sushi-grade tuna. Their signature seared tuna steak, cooked to perfection, is a must-try. The restaurant emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients whenever possible, resulting in dishes bursting with flavor. Their relaxed atmosphere makes it ideal for both casual dinners and special occasions.
2. The Ithaca Chop House: Upscale Tuna Experience
For a more upscale tuna experience, The Ithaca Chop House is an excellent choice. Their menu features expertly prepared tuna dishes, often incorporating seasonal ingredients. Their seared ahi tuna appetizer is a popular choice, known for its delicate flavor and presentation. Expect a sophisticated ambiance and impeccable service.
3. The Fish Market: Simple, Fresh, and Delicious
The Fish Market offers a no-frills approach to seafood, emphasizing the quality of the ingredients. Their tuna salad sandwich is a local favorite, made with fresh, high-quality tuna and served on crusty bread. It's the perfect casual lunch option.
Exploring Ithaca's Diverse Tuna Options
While the restaurants above stand out, Ithaca has many other excellent options. This section categorizes restaurants based on their style and the type of tuna dishes they offer.
Casual Eateries with Great Tuna
- The Corner Deli: Their tuna melts are legendary, piled high with tuna salad, cheese, and crispy bacon.
- Collegetown Bagels: Offers a simple but satisfying tuna salad bagel.
- Sub Zero: Features several tuna sub options, perfect for a quick and tasty meal.
Restaurants with Creative Tuna Dishes
- Roux: Their chef's specials frequently include innovative tuna preparations, showcasing seasonal ingredients.
- Agava: Features a unique fusion menu with some interesting tuna-based dishes.
- State Street Grill: Known for their consistently high-quality seafood, including excellent tuna options.
Fine Dining Establishments Featuring Tuna
- Glenwood Inn: Their elegant menu includes sophisticated tuna dishes, suitable for romantic dinners.
- The Boathouse: Offers stunning waterfront views alongside expertly prepared tuna steaks and sushi.
- Ithaca Beer Company: While primarily known for their beer, they also have a surprisingly good food menu that sometimes includes tuna options.
Beyond the Main Dishes: Tuna Sides and Appetizers
Many Ithaca restaurants offer delicious tuna appetizers and side dishes. These are perfect for sharing or as a light meal.
- Tuna Tartare: Look for this classic appetizer in several upscale restaurants around Ithaca.
- Tuna Poke Bowls: A growing trend, many restaurants are incorporating this Hawaiian classic into their menus.
- Tuna Salad Crostini: A light and flavorful appetizer often found in wine bars and tapas restaurants.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Tuna Restaurant
When selecting a tuna restaurant in Ithaca, consider:
| Factor | Description |
|---|---|
| Freshness | Look for restaurants that emphasize fresh, locally sourced seafood. |
| Sustainability | Inquire about the restaurant's commitment to sustainable fishing practices. |
| Preparation | Consider whether you prefer seared, grilled, raw, or another preparation method. |
| Ambiance | Choose a restaurant with an atmosphere that matches your dining preferences. |
| Price Range | Ithaca offers options for every budget, from casual eateries to fine dining. |
Conclusion: Your Ithaca Tuna Adventure Awaits!
Ithaca offers an abundance of choices for tuna enthusiasts. This guide highlights just a fraction of the excellent restaurants featuring this versatile fish. Whether you're a seasoned foodie or a casual diner, take your time exploring Ithaca's culinary scene and discover your new favorite tuna restaurant. Remember to check menus and make reservations, especially for popular spots. Happy eating!
