Sheepshead Bay, a vibrant Brooklyn neighborhood, is renowned for its incredible Italian-American cuisine. Among its culinary treasures, the calzone reigns supreme. This deep-dish delight, a folded pizza filled with savory ingredients, offers a satisfying and flavorful experience. This guide explores the best 12 calzones in Sheepshead Bay, highlighting what makes each a standout choice. Finding the perfect calzone in this area is a culinary adventure, and this list will guide you to the tastiest stops on your journey. Whether you prefer classic combinations or adventurous fillings, Sheepshead Bay has a calzone to satisfy every craving.
Top Calzone Spots in Sheepshead Bay: A Neighborhood Guide
This list isn't ranked in order of preference; taste is subjective! Each spot offers a unique calzone experience.
1. L&B Spumoni Gardens
- Why it's great: A Sheepshead Bay institution, L&B is famous for its Sicilian-style pizza, and their calzones follow suit. Expect a thick, chewy crust, generously filled with classic combinations. Their ricotta and mozzarella is a must-try.
- Signature Calzone: The classic ricotta and mozzarella calzone.
- Pro Tip: Arrive early, especially on weekends, as lines can get long.
2. Lenny's Pizza
- Why it's great: Lenny's provides a more contemporary take on the calzone, offering creative variations alongside the traditional options. Their crust is known for its light yet satisfying texture.
- Signature Calzone: The "Spicy Italian" calzone, featuring pepperoni, sausage, and jalapeños.
- Pro Tip: Check their daily specials for unique, limited-time calzone offerings.
3. Villabate Alba
- Why it's great: This upscale Italian restaurant offers a refined calzone experience. Expect high-quality ingredients and an elegant presentation.
- Signature Calzone: The "Funghi Calzone," featuring a medley of wild mushrooms and truffle oil.
- Pro Tip: Make a reservation, especially for dinner.
4. Enoteca Maria
- Why it's great: Enoteca Maria offers a unique, rotating menu of calzones prepared by grandmothers from different Italian regions. Every visit offers a chance to experience a new culinary tradition.
- Signature Calzone: The "Nona's Special" – This varies daily depending on the featured grandmother's recipe.
- Pro Tip: Check their website for the current grandmother's menu and their specialties.
5. Grimaldi's Pizzeria (under the Brooklyn Bridge)
While technically not in Sheepshead Bay, its proximity and reputation make it worth mentioning.
- Why it's great: Grimaldi's is a legendary pizza place, known for its coal-fired pies. Their calzones are equally impressive, with a slightly charred, smoky flavor.
- Signature Calzone: The classic pepperoni and cheese calzone.
- Pro Tip: Be prepared for crowds, and consider ordering ahead.
6. Joe's Pizza
- Why it's great: A classic NYC pizza joint, Joe's Pizza offers a consistently reliable calzone at a reasonable price. A good choice for a quick and tasty meal.
- Signature Calzone: The classic cheese calzone. A great way to judge their fresh ingredients and dough.
- Pro Tip: This is a great spot for a casual, no-frills calzone experience.
7. Pizza Moto
- Why it's great: Pizza Moto features a creative, modern menu with unique calzone options that blend Italian traditions with contemporary flavors.
- Signature Calzone: The "Fig and Prosciutto" calzone, a surprisingly delicious combination of sweet and salty flavors.
- Pro Tip: Check their website for seasonal calzone specials.
8. Paulie Gee's (Greenpoint) - A short trip away
Again, slightly outside Sheepshead Bay but highly recommended for pizza connoisseurs.
- Why it's great: Paulie Gee's is a renowned pizzeria known for its exceptional dough and creative toppings. Their calzones reflect this same high quality.
- Signature Calzone: The "Hellboy" calzone, featuring spicy soppressata, pepperoni, and jalapeños.
- Pro Tip: This is a popular spot; expect a wait, especially on weekends.
9. Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana (Coney Island) - Another nearby gem
Another location that's a little outside of Sheepshead Bay, but close enough for a worthwhile trip.
- Why it's great: Totonno's boasts a long history and a reputation for authentic Neapolitan pizza. Their calzones maintain this tradition of quality.
- Signature Calzone: Their classic Margherita calzone.
- Pro Tip: This is a family-run establishment, and they might have limited seating.
10. A casual pizzeria on Emmons Avenue (Many to choose from!)
Emmons Avenue boasts many excellent pizza shops. Look for high customer ratings and reviews. Many offer superior calzones!
- Why it's great: This provides an opportunity to explore hidden gems and discover your personal favorite.
- Signature Calzone: Varies depending on the chosen pizzeria.
- Pro Tip: Walk Emmons Avenue and look for busy spots, fresh ingredients, and enticing aromas.
11. A local Italian deli on Shore Parkway
Many Italian delis on Shore Parkway will offer excellent calzones – often prepared fresh-to-order.
- Why it's great: These are often smaller, family-run businesses who pride themselves on the quality of their ingredients.
- Signature Calzone: This will vary but expect tasty, classic options.
- Pro Tip: Look for those with high Yelp ratings and consistent positive reviews.
12. Your Neighborhood Go-To!
Don't forget to explore the local favorites in your specific part of Sheepshead Bay. Word-of-mouth recommendations can often lead you to the best hidden gems.
- Why it's great: Discover a local favorite and support a small business.
- Signature Calzone: It is a surprise!
- Pro Tip: Ask your neighbors, friends, or local shopkeepers for their recommendations.
This guide provides a starting point for your calzone adventure in Sheepshead Bay. Remember to explore, experiment, and discover your own personal favorite. Happy eating!
