Long Island City (LIC) in NYC boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and pizza is no exception. This neighborhood offers a diverse range of pizza styles, from classic New York slices to creative gourmet pies. Finding the best pizza is subjective, but this guide highlights 11 exceptional pizza places in LIC that cater to various tastes and preferences. This guide covers everything from the best pizza in LIC to hidden gems and trendy spots. Whether you crave a quick slice or a leisurely pizza night out, LIC has something for you.
Classic New York Style: A Timeless Favorite
Many consider New York-style pizza the gold standard. These establishments showcase the quintessential thin crust, generous toppings, and a taste of New York City history.
1. Pizzatown: A LIC Institution
Pizzatown is a LIC institution known for its consistently excellent classic New York slices. Their secret? Fresh ingredients and a time-tested recipe passed down through generations. The cheese pull is legendary, and the crispy crust is perfectly charred.
- Specialty: Classic cheese and pepperoni slices.
- Ambiance: Casual, quick-service.
- Price: $
2. Rosy's Pizza: Neighborhood Gem
Rosy's offers a more local, neighborhood feel. Their pizza is a bit thicker than your average New York slice, with a slightly softer crust. This makes it incredibly satisfying, especially for those who prefer a more substantial bite.
- Specialty: Sicilian and Grandma-style pies.
- Ambiance: Cozy, family-friendly.
- Price: $
Beyond the Classic: Exploring Diverse Pizza Styles
LIC's pizza scene isn't limited to tradition. Many pizzerias embrace innovation, offering unique styles and flavor combinations.
3. The Dough Project: Artisanal Pizza Perfection
The Dough Project elevates pizza to an art form. They use locally sourced ingredients and unique topping combinations. Expect creative, flavorful pies that showcase the chef's expertise.
- Specialty: Gourmet pizzas with seasonal ingredients.
- Ambiance: Trendy, upscale.
- Price: $$
4. Arepera Guacuco: Venezuelan Flair
This spot offers a unique fusion of Venezuelan and Italian cuisine. Their arepas are a must-try, but their pizzas showcase a delightful combination of Latin American and Italian flavors.
- Specialty: Arepas and pizzas with unique Venezuelan-inspired toppings.
- Ambiance: Lively, casual.
- Price: $
5. Grimaldi's Pizzeria (Under the Brooklyn Bridge): A LIC Borderline Treat
While technically located just outside LIC, under the Brooklyn Bridge, Grimaldi's proximity and reputation make it worth including. Their coal-fired pizzas are legendary for their smoky flavor and perfectly charred crust.
- Specialty: Coal-fired pizzas.
- Ambiance: Iconic, bustling.
- Price: $$
Hidden Gems and Unexpected Delights
Sometimes, the best finds are the ones you least expect. These hidden gems offer unique pizza experiences in LIC.
6. Anella: Wood-Fired Pizza with a View
Anella combines delicious wood-fired pizza with stunning city views. Their pizzas are crafted with high-quality ingredients, offering a memorable dining experience.
- Specialty: Wood-fired pizzas with stunning views.
- Ambiance: Romantic, upscale.
- Price: $$
7. LIC Market: Food Hall Fun
The LIC Market offers a diverse selection of food vendors, including a few excellent pizza options. It's a great place to sample different styles and find your new favorite.
- Specialty: Variety of pizza styles from different vendors.
- Ambiance: Energetic, food hall atmosphere.
- Price: Varies
Going Beyond the Traditional Slice
The following entries offer a unique take on pizza and related experiences:
8. Lilia (Williamsburg - Close Proximity): Upscale Italian Experience
Although a bit further out in Williamsburg, Lilia's proximity and renowned pasta dishes make it an excellent pairing for a pizza-related excursion. Their pizza is a highly sought-after experience.
- Specialty: Hand-crafted pasta, pizza as a complement.
- Ambiance: Upscale, modern Italian
- Price: $$
9. Casa Enrique: Authentic Mexican with Pizza Inspiration
This restaurant offers a glimpse into authentic Mexican cuisine, but the flavors can inspire creative interpretations of pizza toppings.
- Specialty: Authentic Mexican dishes.
- Ambiance: Casual, vibrant.
- Price: $
10. Olio e Limone: A Pizza-Adjacent Italian Gem
Olio e Limone might not be strictly a pizzeria, but their pasta dishes and other Italian fare are perfect companions for pizza night.
- Specialty: Authentic Italian food, with pizza as a potential companion
- Ambiance: Casual-upscale Italian.
- Price: $$
11. Your Own Homemade Pizza Night
Sometimes, the best pizza is made at home! Experiment with different recipes and toppings for a fun and customizable experience.
Choosing Your Perfect LIC Pizza Slice: A Summary
This guide highlights just a fraction of the excellent pizza options available in Long Island City. The best pizza for you depends on your preferences and desired experience. Whether you crave a classic New York slice or something more adventurous, LIC has something to satisfy your pizza cravings. Remember to check websites or call ahead for hours and menus before you go. Happy eating!
