Bensonhurst, a vibrant neighborhood in Brooklyn, might not be the first place that springs to mind when you think of Mexican food. However, this diverse community boasts a surprising number of excellent Mexican restaurants, offering a delicious range of flavors and styles. This guide dives into the top 10, highlighting what makes each a must-visit for any Mexican food enthusiast. We'll explore their specialties, atmospheres, and what sets them apart in this unexpected culinary landscape. This list is curated to provide you with the best of Bensonhurst's Mexican restaurant scene.
Top 10 Mexican Restaurants in Bensonhurst: A Detailed Look
Finding authentic Mexican food in unexpected places is always an exciting culinary adventure. Bensonhurst, with its multicultural tapestry, delivers just that. Let's explore the gems this neighborhood offers:
1. Taqueria El Rey: Authentic Mexican Flavors
Taqueria El Rey consistently earns rave reviews for its authentic Mexican cuisine. Their tacos are legendary, boasting perfectly grilled meats, fresh toppings, and flavorful tortillas. The atmosphere is casual and friendly, perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. They stand out for their commitment to traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients. One Yelp review perfectly captures the essence: "Best tacos I've ever had in NYC!"
Specialty: Tacos al Pastor, Carne Asada
Atmosphere: Casual and lively
2. La Tapatia: Family-Style Mexican Dining
La Tapatia provides a more family-style dining experience. They are known for their generous portions and home-style cooking. The menu extends beyond tacos, offering a wide selection of enchiladas, burritos, and combination plates. The warm and welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a larger group.
Specialty: Mole Poblano, Chimichangas
Atmosphere: Warm and inviting, family-friendly
3. Los Dos Amigos: A Hidden Gem for Authentic Mexican Cuisine
Los Dos Amigos is a true hidden gem, often overlooked but deeply appreciated by locals in the know. This small, unassuming restaurant offers incredibly flavorful and authentic dishes at reasonable prices. They prioritize fresh ingredients and traditional cooking techniques.
Specialty: Pozole, Carnitas
Atmosphere: Small, cozy, and authentic
4. El Mariachi Loco: Lively Atmosphere and Great Margaritas
For a more lively atmosphere, El Mariachi Loco is the place to be. They are known for their strong margaritas and festive ambiance. While the food is good, the energy and entertainment are a major draw. It's the perfect spot for a celebratory dinner or a night out with friends.
Specialty: Margaritas, Fajitas
Atmosphere: Lively and festive
5. Tacos Jalisco: Quick Bites and Great Value
Tacos Jalisco is your go-to spot for a quick and affordable Mexican meal. While it might not have the most elaborate menu, it delivers consistently delicious tacos at great value. Their efficiency and flavorful tacos make it a popular lunch spot.
Specialty: Tacos al Carbon, Suadero
Atmosphere: Fast-paced and efficient
6. Mi Ranchito: Hearty Portions and Southern Mexican Flavors
Mi Ranchito offers a taste of Southern Mexican cuisine, known for its hearty portions and rich flavors. Expect dishes packed with flavor and generous servings. Their menu showcases a broader range of regional specialties beyond the typical NYC Mexican fare.
Specialty: Cochinita Pibil, Chile Rellenos
Atmosphere: Relaxed and comfortable
7. La Perla: Seafood Delights with a Mexican Twist
If you are looking for a seafood twist on Mexican cuisine, La Perla is your destination. This restaurant highlights fresh seafood incorporated into traditional Mexican dishes. This is a unique offering among Bensonhurst's Mexican restaurants.
Specialty: Ceviche, Shrimp Tacos
Atmosphere: Casual and fresh
8. El Sol: A Classic Mexican Experience
El Sol is a classic Mexican restaurant offering all the favorites. Think of it as a reliable and consistent option with a familiar menu and solid execution. They provide a good all-around Mexican dining experience.
Specialty: Burritos, Quesadillas
Atmosphere: Traditional and comfortable
9. Casa Del Sol: Home-Style Cooking and Warm Hospitality
Casa Del Sol embodies the warmth and generosity of home-style Mexican cooking. The menu showcases simple yet flavorful dishes prepared with care. It's a place where you can feel the love and passion in every bite.
Specialty: Enchiladas Verdes, Menudo (on weekends)
Atmosphere: Homey and welcoming
10. Taqueria La Mexicana: Your Late-Night Taco Cravings Solved
Taqueria La Mexicana is a boon for late-night taco cravings. They often have extended hours, making them a perfect stop after a night out or for a late-night snack. While their menu is simpler, their tacos are reliably delicious.
Specialty: Late-night tacos, Al Pastor
Atmosphere: Simple and functional
Finding Your Perfect Mexican Meal in Bensonhurst
Bensonhurst's Mexican food scene offers a delicious diversity, catering to every taste and preference. From casual taco stands to family-style restaurants, the options are plentiful. This guide helps you navigate the best of what the area has to offer, encouraging you to explore and discover your new favorite Mexican restaurant in this unexpected culinary haven. Remember to check each restaurant's hours and consider making a reservation, especially during peak times. Enjoy your culinary adventure!
