The Upper West Side boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and within that, a fierce competition for the title of "best bagel." Forget the pre-packaged, supermarket disappointments – we're diving deep into the neighborhood's hidden gems and established favorites to bring you the definitive list of the top 10 bagel shops. This isn't just about the dough; it's about the texture, the perfect chew, the impeccable toppings, and that indefinable something that makes a truly great bagel. We've sampled dozens to bring you this curated list, taking into account factors ranging from the quality of the ingredients to the overall customer experience.
Top Bagel Shops: A Neighborhood Exploration
Finding the perfect bagel is a personal quest. What one person considers the "best" might be another's "meh." But these 10 shops consistently receive rave reviews and represent the diverse styles of bagel-making found on the UWS. This guide breaks down why these spots earn a place on this coveted list.
1. Absolute Bagels
This beloved institution is a UWS staple. Their bagels are known for their perfectly chewy texture, a delightful balance of crisp exterior and soft interior. They offer a wide variety of spreads and toppings, catering to every palate.
- Why they're great: Consistency is key, and Absolute Bagels delivers. They've mastered the art of the classic New York bagel.
- Must-try: Their everything bagel with cream cheese is legendary.
2. Zabar's
Zabar's isn't just a grocery store; it's a UWS landmark. Their bagel selection is vast, consistently fresh, and always a reliable choice. The sheer variety ensures something for everyone.
- Why they're great: Convenience combined with quality. You can grab your bagel and other groceries all in one place.
- Must-try: Their poppy seed bagels are a classic for a reason.
3. Ess-a-Bagel
While technically not on the UWS (it's a short trip from the neighborhood), Ess-a-Bagel's reputation precedes it. Their bagels are known for their large size and their commitment to traditional methods. This is a must-visit for the serious bagel connoisseur.
- Why they're great: A true NYC institution that maintains a high level of quality.
- Must-try: The salt bagel with lox is an indulgent experience.
4. Barney Greengrass
More than just a bagel shop, Barney Greengrass is an Upper West Side institution. While their bagels might not be the focus, they pair perfectly with their famous smoked fish.
- Why they're great: Experience and ambiance. Eating a bagel here is an experience in itself.
- Must-try: A bagel with smoked salmon and cream cheese – a classic combination.
5. H&H Bagels
Another slightly further-afield choice, but still worth mentioning for those willing to make the short journey. H&H is a legendary New York bagel shop with a robust menu and dedicated following.
- Why they're great: A true New York institution with a dedicated customer base.
- Must-try: The classic everything bagel is a masterpiece of flavor and texture.
6. Murray's Bagels
A newer entry to the scene, Murray's has quickly gained a loyal following. Their bagels are praised for their freshness and unique flavor combinations.
- Why they're great: A fresh perspective on classic bagels.
- Must-try: Experiment with their seasonal specials.
7. Black Seed Bagels
Located a bit further downtown, but frequently cited by UWS residents as their "go-to". Black Seed is known for its unique wood-fired baking process that delivers a distinctive smoky flavor.
- Why they're great: Unique flavor profile and high-quality ingredients.
- Must-try: Their classic everything bagel with a twist, thanks to the wood-fired taste.
8. Orwashers Bakery
This bakery offers more than just bagels, but their bagels hold their own. A local favorite with consistently good quality.
- Why they're great: A reliable neighborhood option that provides a solid bagel experience.
- Must-try: Their plain bagels are surprisingly delicious.
9. Leo's Bagels
This location offers a wide selection of bagels and related goods, making it ideal for varied taste.
- Why they're great: Variety and convenience for a quick grab-and-go.
- Must-try: Try something you might not normally order, they do a great job with uncommon choices.
10. Manhattan Bagel
A well-known chain, but this particular location maintains a level of quality that rivals smaller shops.
- Why they're great: Reliable quality and consistent availability, even during peak hours.
- Must-try: Their sesame bagels are simple but perfectly executed.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Your Bagel
Beyond the specific shop, consider these factors when choosing your perfect Upper West Side bagel:
- Freshness: The best bagels are served fresh, ideally the same day they're baked.
- Texture: Look for a balance of chewiness and crispness.
- Toppings: Experiment! From classic sesame to everything bagels, the possibilities are endless.
- Spread: Cream cheese is a classic, but explore other options like flavored butter or smoked salmon.
Conclusion: Your Upper West Side Bagel Adventure Awaits!
The Upper West Side offers a diverse and delicious bagel landscape. This list provides a starting point for your own bagel journey; explore, discover, and most importantly, enjoy! Let us know in the comments which bagel shop is your favorite. Happy eating!
