Alto Cinco, perched atop the Arlo NoMad hotel in New York City, offers a unique blend of upscale Mexican cuisine and breathtaking panoramic views. This blog post will thoroughly examine Alto Cinco, exploring its menu, atmosphere, service, and overall value based on various reviews and personal experiences to provide you with a comprehensive understanding before your visit. We'll be focusing on what makes Alto Cinco stand out – and where it might fall short – to help you decide if it's the right spot for your next NYC dining experience.
The Alto Cinco Menu: A Taste of Upscale Mexican
Alto Cinco's menu is a carefully curated selection of modern Mexican dishes, emphasizing fresh, high-quality ingredients. While it's not a traditional taqueria, it offers a refined take on familiar favorites and some more adventurous options.
Appetizers & Snacks
The appetizer selection includes creative twists on classics like guacamole (often featuring unique additions) and esquites (Mexican street corn). Many reviewers praise the freshness and vibrant flavors of these dishes, highlighting their sophisticated preparation. However, some find the portions smaller than expected for the price point.
Main Courses
The main courses range from familiar dishes like tacos and enchiladas to more unique offerings. Tacos, for example, might feature unusual proteins or creative flavor combinations. Enchiladas are often prepared with gourmet sauces and fillings. Reviews consistently highlight the quality of the ingredients, but some comment on the richness of certain dishes, which might be too heavy for some palates.
Desserts
The dessert menu typically features traditional Mexican sweets with modern presentations. Churros and flan are frequently mentioned in positive reviews, praised for their deliciousness and artful plating. However, dessert options can be limited, and some find the prices a bit steep for the portion size.
Here's a sample menu item breakdown based on aggregated online reviews:
| Dish Category | Example Dish | Price Range (approx.) | Review Sentiment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appetizer | Guacamole | $15 - $20 | Mostly positive, some comments on portion size |
| Main Course | Tacos al Pastor | $20 - $25 | Positive, comments on high quality ingredients |
| Main Course | Enchiladas | $22 - $28 | Mixed, some find them rich |
| Dessert | Churros con Chocolate | $12 - $15 | Very positive |
Atmosphere and Ambiance: Rooftop Views and Chic Decor
Alto Cinco's primary draw is its stunning location. The rooftop setting provides unparalleled panoramic views of the New York City skyline, particularly breathtaking at sunset. The atmosphere is generally described as chic and sophisticated, with a lively but not overly loud ambiance. The decor blends modern elements with subtle Mexican influences.
However, the rooftop location can be affected by weather conditions. Reviews mention that on windy or rainy days, the experience might be less pleasant.
Service at Alto Cinco: Professionalism and Efficiency
The level of service at Alto Cinco is generally described as professional and attentive. Staff are usually praised for their knowledge of the menu and their willingness to provide recommendations. However, some reviews note occasional inconsistencies in service speed, particularly during peak hours.
Overall Value and Final Verdict: Splurge-Worthy?
Alto Cinco is undeniably a high-end dining experience. The prices reflect the quality of the ingredients, the unique location, and the overall upscale atmosphere. Whether or not it’s worth the cost depends on your priorities. If you're looking for a special occasion dinner with incredible views and delicious, refined Mexican food, Alto Cinco delivers. However, if you're on a tight budget or seeking a more casual dining experience, other options in NYC might be more suitable.
Tips for Your Alto Cinco Visit:
- Make a reservation: This is crucial, especially for dinner, weekend brunch, or sunset views.
- Consider the weather: Check the forecast before going, as the rooftop setting is vulnerable to the elements.
- Arrive early for sunset: To maximize your view, aim to arrive at least 30 minutes before sunset.
- Check the dress code: While not overly formal, Alto Cinco maintains a sophisticated atmosphere.
Alto Cinco offers a unique NYC dining experience. While the price point is high, the combination of exceptional food, stunning views, and generally excellent service makes it a worthwhile splurge for many. Ultimately, whether it’s "worth it" depends on your personal preferences and budget. But based on the preponderance of reviews, it's a restaurant worth considering for a memorable New York City meal.
