New York City, a culinary melting pot, offers a surprising diversity of mac and cheese experiences beyond the expected. From classic comfort food to elevated gourmet versions, the city boasts an impressive array of restaurants serving up this cheesy delight. This guide dives deep into thirteen spots where you can find some of the best mac and cheese NYC has to offer, catering to every palate and preference.
Classic Comfort: Mac & Cheese Done Right
These establishments represent the heart of what mac and cheese should be – creamy, cheesy, and utterly satisfying.
1. Clinton St. Baking Company: A Lower East Side Staple
Clinton St. Baking Company isn't just known for its pancakes; their mac and cheese is a hidden gem. Expect a generous portion of perfectly cooked pasta swimming in a rich, creamy cheese sauce. The simplicity is its strength, offering a nostalgic comfort food experience. It’s a classic for a reason.
- Ambiance: Casual, bustling, classic diner feel.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: Often served with a side of their famous biscuits for dipping.
2. The Smith: Reliable Comfort Across Locations
With several locations across the city, The Smith provides a consistently delicious mac and cheese experience. Their version is a well-executed take on the classic – creamy, cheesy, and satisfying. While not groundbreaking, it's a dependable choice when you're craving a comforting bowl.
- Ambiance: Upscale casual, great for groups.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: Offers variations, including lobster mac and cheese at some locations.
3. JG Melon: An Upper East Side Institution
JG Melon is a legendary Upper East Side spot, famous for its burgers and, you guessed it, mac and cheese. Their version is a simple, yet expertly executed comfort food classic. The creamy texture and sharp cheddar flavor make it a must-try for anyone in the neighborhood.
- Ambiance: Classic American bar and grill.
- Price: Moderate to High
- Unique Element: The nostalgic atmosphere adds to the experience.
Elevated Mac & Cheese: Gourmet Twists and Unique Flavors
These restaurants elevate the classic mac and cheese, incorporating unique ingredients and sophisticated techniques to create truly memorable dishes.
4. Lilia: Pasta Perfection in Williamsburg
Lilia's pasta dishes are legendary, and their mac and cheese is no exception. While not always on the menu, when it is, it's an experience. Expect impeccably cooked pasta in a rich, flavorful sauce made with high-quality cheeses. This is mac and cheese elevated to an art form.
- Ambiance: Chic and modern, yet relaxed.
- Price: High
- Unique Element: The ever-changing menu keeps things interesting. Often features seasonal variations.
5. Via Carota: West Village Charm and Unexpected Delights
Via Carota’s menu changes frequently, but when their mac and cheese appears, it's worth grabbing. Expect a dish full of fresh pasta in a creamy sauce with a touch of unexpected flair. The rustic charm of the restaurant only enhances the experience.
- Ambiance: Charming West Village Trattoria
- Price: High
- Unique Element: The ever-changing menu keeps the mac and cheese exciting.
6. The River Café: Stunning Views and Exquisite Food
For a truly special occasion, consider The River Café. Their mac and cheese isn't just a side dish; it's an experience. Expect impeccable ingredients, a perfectly balanced sauce, and a stunning view of the Manhattan skyline. The price reflects the quality and ambiance, but it’s a memorable dining experience.
- Ambiance: Upscale, romantic, stunning views.
- Price: Very High
- Unique Element: The location and breathtaking views.
Unique Takes: Beyond the Classic
These restaurants offer mac and cheese with unique twists and unusual ingredients that redefine the dish.
7. Shake Shack: A Fast-Casual Favorite
Shake Shack's mac and cheese is a surprising delight. It’s a creamy, well-seasoned option perfectly suited for a quick and satisfying meal. It’s a solid option when you need a fast-casual mac fix.
- Ambiance: Fast-casual, lively atmosphere.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: The accessibility and convenient location.
8. Parm: A Classic Italian-American Twist
Parm serves up a delicious mac and cheese with a distinctly Italian-American flair. Expect a comforting and satisfying dish with slightly different flavors and textures compared to traditional mac and cheese. It's a reliable spot for a tasty and approachable version.
- Ambiance: Casual, lively, classic Italian-American feel.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: The Italian-American influence on the dish.
9. Roberta's Pizza: Unexpected Mac & Cheese in Bushwick
Roberta's Pizza is known for its excellent pies, but their mac and cheese is a pleasant surprise. Their version is often a slightly unconventional take on the dish, highlighting different cheeses and flavors. Expect a unique and delicious culinary adventure.
- Ambiance: Casual, trendy, Brooklyn vibe.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: The unexpected location and unconventional approach to the dish.
Beyond the Usual: Specialty Mac & Cheese Experiences
10. Macdougal's Mac & Cheese: A Unique Concept
This restaurant is dedicated to mac and cheese, offering a wide variety of creative options. Expect unusual and adventurous flavor combinations that push the boundaries of what mac and cheese can be. It's a must-try for adventurous eaters.
- Ambiance: Casual, fun, focused on mac and cheese.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: The sheer variety of mac and cheese options.
11. Cheeky Sandwiches: A Different Kind of Sandwich Shop
Cheeky Sandwiches also offers a unique mac and cheese. Think of it as a side dish that could be a main course. Expect a well-executed version that complements their sandwich menu perfectly.
- Ambiance: Casual, fun, a great sandwich experience.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: Part of a very diverse and delicious sandwich menu.
12. Artichoke Basille's Pizza: Unexpected Pizza Place Delight
While known for its pizza, Artichoke Basille's offers mac and cheese that’s worth a try. Their version might not be the star of the show, but it's a surprisingly enjoyable accompaniment to their pizza. It's a fun bonus for your pizza order!
- Ambiance: Casual, lively, known for pizza.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: An unexpected mac and cheese addition to a beloved pizza place.
13. Hill Country Barbecue Market: A Texas-Style Twist
For a different take on mac and cheese, try Hill Country Barbecue Market. Their version reflects a Texan influence, often featuring smoky or spicy elements. It’s a great option for those seeking a unique flavor profile.
- Ambiance: Casual, lively, Texas BBQ atmosphere.
- Price: Moderate
- Unique Element: The smoked and spicy Texas influence on the dish.
This list offers a starting point for your NYC mac and cheese adventure. Remember to check menus and availability as offerings can change. Happy eating!
