French toast, that golden-brown, eggy delight, is a breakfast staple loved by many. But finding the perfect French toast can be a quest. Fear not, Buffalo foodies! This guide dives deep into the city's best spots for this breakfast champion, uncovering hidden gems and well-loved classics. Whether you prefer it classic or with a gourmet twist, this list has something for every palate. We've scoured reviews, visited restaurants, and tasted our way through the city to bring you the 12 best French toast restaurants in Buffalo.
The Classics: Tried and True French Toast Havens
These establishments have earned their reputation for consistently delivering delicious French toast, often with a home-style feel.
1. Sophia's Restaurant: A Buffalo Institution
Sophia's is a Buffalo landmark, and for good reason. Their French toast is a timeless classic, featuring thick-cut bread perfectly soaked in a rich custard. The portions are generous, making it a satisfying and affordable option. Many reviewers cite its fluffy texture and subtle sweetness as highlights.
- Key Feature: Classic, generous portions, affordable.
- Pro Tip: Arrive early on weekends, as lines can form quickly.
2. Henry's Diner: Retro Charm Meets Delicious French Toast
Henry's Diner boasts a retro ambiance and a menu full of comfort food favorites. Their French toast stands out with its use of challah bread, providing a slightly sweeter and richer flavor than traditional white bread. This option offers a pleasing combination of texture and taste.
- Key Feature: Challah bread, retro diner atmosphere.
- Pro Tip: Check their daily specials; they sometimes offer unique French toast variations.
3. Parkway Restaurant: A Neighborhood Favorite
Parkway Restaurant is a beloved neighborhood spot known for its friendly service and hearty portions. Their French toast recipe is a closely guarded secret, but many describe it as perfectly eggy and satisfying. This option is perfect for a casual, relaxed breakfast.
- Key Feature: Hearty portions, friendly atmosphere.
- Pro Tip: Their home fries are a great side to complement the French toast.
Gourmet French Toast Experiences: Elevating the Classic
These restaurants take French toast to the next level, incorporating unique ingredients and creative preparations.
4. Toutant: Elevated Southern Comfort Food
Toutant offers a more sophisticated take on Southern comfort food. Their French toast might feature brioche bread, a special spice blend, or seasonal fruit compotes. It's a flavorful and refined experience.
- Key Feature: Upscale ambiance, creative variations.
- Pro Tip: Make a reservation, especially for weekend brunch.
5. Westside Bazaar: A Multicultural French Toast Adventure
Westside Bazaar is a food hall showcasing diverse cuisines. You're likely to find unique French toast interpretations here, maybe a version incorporating spices or flavors from different cultures. This offers a surprising culinary adventure.
- Key Feature: Unique international flavors.
- Pro Tip: Explore the entire bazaar for a full culinary experience.
6. The Black Sheep Restaurant: Unexpected Flavors
The Black Sheep consistently impresses with its creative and unexpected menu items. Their French toast is no exception. Expect exciting combinations of flavors and textures that elevate the dish beyond the ordinary.
- Key Feature: Innovative and unexpected flavor combinations.
- Pro Tip: Check their menu online before your visit to see the current French toast offering.
Hidden Gems: Discover Buffalo's Best-Kept Secrets
These less-known spots often offer exceptional French toast without the long waits.
7. Taqueria Los Mayas: A Surprising Delight
While known primarily for its tacos, Taqueria Los Mayas may offer a surprisingly delicious French toast. It is worth asking!
- Key Feature: Hidden gem, unexpected deliciousness (possibly).
- Pro Tip: Check if they have French toast on the menu; availability can vary.
8. Yalleys: A Local Favorite
Yalleys is a local favorite known for its quality ingredients and friendly service. Their French toast may be a simple but well-executed version of the classic, relying on high-quality bread and a perfect custard recipe.
- Key Feature: High-quality ingredients, local favorite.
- Pro Tip: This is a great option for a quiet, comfortable breakfast.
9. Community Beer Works: Brewpub Brunch
Community Beer Works may offer French toast as part of their weekend brunch menu. The pairing of French toast and craft beer could be an interesting combination.
- Key Feature: French toast with craft beer.
- Pro Tip: Check their website for their brunch menu and hours.
Beyond the Plate: French Toast with a Twist
These spots offer unique French toast presentations or additions.
10. Oliver's: A Stylish Brunch Spot
Oliver's is a stylish brunch spot where presentation matters. Their French toast might feature artful plating and interesting accompaniments. It's a delicious Instagrammable meal.
- Key Feature: Stylish presentation, interesting accompaniments.
- Pro Tip: Make a reservation, as this spot is popular.
11. Greco: Mediterranean Flair
Greco may offer a Mediterranean-inspired take on French toast, incorporating flavors and ingredients from the region. Expect a unique and flavorful experience.
- Key Feature: Mediterranean-inspired flavors.
- Pro Tip: Check their menu for seasonal variations.
12. Pho Dollar: Vietnamese Twist (Possibly)
Some Vietnamese restaurants may have inventive takes on breakfast, so Pho Dollar warrants checking out. While not guaranteed, it's worth exploring this possibility.
- Key Feature: Potential for a unique Vietnamese-inspired French toast.
- Pro Tip: Ask about any special breakfast items when visiting.
This list offers a starting point for your French toast adventures in Buffalo. Remember that menus can change, so it's always a good idea to call ahead or check online before your visit. Happy eating!
